Religious Children Have Trouble Distinguishing Reality from Fiction - RiseEarth

Religious Children Have Trouble Distinguishing Reality from Fiction



by Anna Hunt
Waking Times

A study conducted by researchers led by Kathleen H. Corriveau of Boston University examined how religious exposure affects a child’s ability to distinguish between fact and fiction. They found that religious exposure at an early age has a surprising effect: it makes children less able to differentiate between reality and fantasy.

The researchers presented three different types of stories – religious, fantastical and realistic – to a group of 5 and 6-year olds. Religious children were divided into three groups: children exposed to the Christian religion either as churchgoers who attended public school, non-churchgoers who attended parochial school, or churchgoers who attended parochial school. The fourth group of children included non-churchgoing children who attended public school and had no exposure to religion in either church or school. The goal of the research was to find out if religious exposure would affect the child’s ability to identify if the lead character in each of the stories was real or make-believe.


The study found that children who attended church services and/or were enrolled in a parochial school had a much harder time differentiating between fact and fiction when compared to children of non-religious background. The study, published in the journal Cognitive Science, states:
“The results suggest that exposure to religious ideas has a powerful impact on children’s differentiation between reality and fiction, not just for religious stories but also for fantastical stories.”
The most surprising aspect of the research was how children’s upbringing affected how they judge the main character in fantastical stories. These stories included events, brought about by magic (in Study 1) or without reference to magic (in Study 2), that would ordinarily be impossible. Secular children were much more likely to identify the characters in these stories as make-believe, while children with religious exposure were more likely to identify them as real.

The researchers found that all children, regardless of their religious background, identified the main character of the realistic stories as real. When presented with religious stories, that included “ordinarily impossible events brought about by divine intervention,” children who attended church or were enrolled in a parochial school, or both, identified the lead character as real, which isn’t unexpected. On the other hand, children with no religious exposure judged the protagonist of the religious stories to be fictional.

The study’s authors suggest:
“…even if children have no natural inclination to believe in divine or superhuman agency, religious instruction can readily lead them to do so.”

“…religious teaching, especially exposure to miracle stories, leads children to a more generic receptivity toward the impossible, that is, a more wide-ranging acceptance that the impossible can happen in defiance of ordinary causal relations.”
The results of this study could lead one to think that religion, intentionally or not, takes advantage of the natural gullibility of children and molds them into believing in the power of divine characters presented in religious teachings and literature such as the Bible. About 28 percent of Americans who participated in the 2013-2014 Gallup survey believe that the Bible is the actual word of God and should be interpreted literally, while another 47 percent think that the Bible is inspired by the word of God. It is pretty clear that we are not born believers, but are shaped into believers depending on our exposure to religious teachings.

It is difficult to prove if growing up in a religious setting turns children into better people, and some studies have even shown that religious children are meaner and more punitive than secular children. The study by Corriveau et al. identifies an addition effect of religious teachings and how they create tremendous support for antiquated and fantastical stories by feeding them to children from an early age, giving the powers that be the ability to use religion for the justification of impractical or even malevolent acts.

The full study can be viewed here:
http://www.bu.edu/learninglab/files/2012/05/Corriveau-Chen-Harris-in-press.pdf

About the Author:

Anna Hunt is a staff writer for WakingTimes.com and an entrepreneur with over a decade of experience in research and editorial writing. She and her husband run a preparedness e-store outlet at www.offgridoutpost.com, offering GMO-free storable food and emergency kits. Anna is also a certified Hatha yoga instructor. She enjoys raising her children and being a voice for optimal human health and wellness. Read more of her excellent articles here. Visit her essential oils store here.

Sources:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/07/21/children-religion-fact-fiction_n_5607009.html
http://www.medicaldaily.com/fantasy-or-reality-children-religious-backgrounds...

Sponsored Links


FREE subscription to Receive Quality Stories Straight in your Inbox!

4 comments:

  1. According to me these stories included occasions, achieved by enchantment (in Study 1) or without reference to enchantment (in Study 2), that would normally be unimaginable. So, we should read such stories to have good change in life. Any how, I try to find best reviews of https://www.topreviewstars.com/how-to-hire-a-top-thesis-or-dissertation-editing-service/ but when i come this site then got a lot of interesting stories from here.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello guys. Can recommend for a parents to further cool service. I think it removes further hardship. In fact, this should be considered as an easy research and writing process once you know all what it takes to carry out a perfect research paper official site and any conscientious student who thinks of succeeding in a prior research and writing must be prepared to carry out research more than what was done in the class. For this reason, you must be able to start as soon as the topic for the paper is approved. In such a case, you will be the one in person to decide on the topic. This will however be based on a previous research you had done or on any studies done by another researcher.

    Before you decide on what to write about, you should think about the time limit set for the research and writing. Remember that this type of academic work will be a very certain pursuit and you will have to work within a given time limit. Therefore, you must be sure that you have all the resources or materials at hand to compose the essay. Your topic should also have a direction. It should not be broad enough. Remember that your essay may be a vague quest if you write all the fine materials but fail to prove something scholastic.

    If you are certain that your essay will be dependent on a previous research, you must be versed with all what obtains in that previous research. There is no way you can conveniently write on something in which you have no knowledge about. Keep in mind that you must know everything about that research and not just a bit of everything about it. Take note that you may be called up at any time to defend what you have written in your essay.

    Use an outline to write your essay and make sure that you write with a draft. The outline is very necessary because this is a serious research and writing. You may come across points that you find either irrelevant or relevant to your essay. The outline makes it feasible and flexible for them to be included in your paper. This is also true if you will want to change the course or direction of your writing.

    Essay prior research should be concluded in a manner similar to every perfect essay. At the close of your essay, the reader should know what stand or position you have taken. This position should be stated unwaveringly. Your essay should be properly revised and edited. Make sure that you give enough time to this. Revision and editing are amongst the most important features in research and writing. Your essay needs to have a perfect finishing. Make sure that all your ideas are linked to each other; make sure that they are represented logically and chronologically and make sure that the reader understands what you intended to say.

    ReplyDelete